Archer and Hughes (2011) identify independent practice as a critical learning stage that should be used under specific conditions to ensure its potential effect is realized. According to them, it must be deployed when students have developed the desired levels of proficiency and confidence in the new material during guided practice (Archer & Hughes, 2011). This ensures that students are prepared to take action for some time without immediate support from the teacher.
One clear indicator of the beginning of independent practice, then, is when a student can perform the skill or demonstrate adequate mastery, with only a few minimal errors during guided practice. This cue suggests that the student has mastered, or, more appropriately, learned, the knowledge in the form of a skill well enough to start practicing on his own. Archer and Hughes (2011) note that during this stage of guided practice, the teacher also offers many opportunities for choral responding, whereby students give both unison feedback to the teacher and correct mistakes. This recursive process is meant to ensure mastery of learning and to identify and dispel any misunderstandings before the student works independently.
Another important consideration is complexity or familiarity with the task. Independent practice should be introduced gradually, focusing first on simpler, more closely related tasks before proceeding to more complex ones as learners build confidence and competence. Being so fair, the incremental approach leaves no room for students to feel overwhelmed and provides an opportunity to build on the success of tasks (Archer & Hughes, 2011).
Also, independent practice should begin when the student demonstrates autonomy and self-regulation. This means they can do the task and have some idea of how to approach it, demonstrating strategic knowledge and problem-solving capabilities. Archer and Hughes also indicate that teachers should model and explicitly teach these strategies during guided practice to help students prepare for independent work. Learning environment organization to support independent practice (Archer & Hughes, 2011). This involves clear instructions, readily available resources, and a setting free of distractions and conducive to work.
Reference
Archer, A. L., & Hughes, C. A. (2011). Explicit instruction: Effective and efficient teaching. Guilford Publications.