Lesson Plan 1
Lesson Plan Rationale (see question prompts in Lesson Plan Instructions)
The lesson will provide the students with the opportunity to help struggling students associate sounds and letters, which is an appropriate activity for primary students in the alphabetic phase of reading (Temple et al., 2018). Children in this phase are looking at the relations between individual letters and individual sounds (Temple et al., 2018). Therefore, according to the principles of effective reading instruction, the goal of the teaching of alphabetic readers should be to help them notice more and more letters as well as the sounds with which they are associated (Temple et al., 2018). The lesson provides students with a framework of how letters can be learned as they gain an association between words, their sound, and letters (Bender & Larkin, 2003). It helps to focus on the common letter-to-sound matches using picture sorts, which was proposed by Temple et al. (2018). The lesson plan can be extended to include a variety of print and digital materials. Picture sorts are available online for free or for a small fee, which makes it easy to include them in lessons and homework. At the same time, there is a variety of alphabet songs, and children can be encouraged to look for such videos and share them with the class. Therefore, the lesson plan is appropriate from the theoretical viewpoint.
A novice teacher may experience significant problems with instruction and discipline. The primary problem is that the students are struggling readers, which means that the teacher will need to provide more guidance than with average students (Bender & Larkin, 2003). Therefore, a beginner educator may find it challenging to find a balance between modeling and individual work. At the same time, novice teachers may encounter an issue with discipline due to the lack of knowledge about what noise and distraction levels are appropriate for the particular age of students. I can recommend the novice teacher to visit lessons of proficient teachers and watch online lessons to find the balance.
Lesson Plan 2
Lesson Plan Rationale (see question prompts in Lesson Plan Instructions)
The proposed lesson will help the class to learn comprehension by acquiring close reading and note-taking skills. According to Temple, Ogle, Crawford, and Freppon (2018), close reading, or hermeneutics, is the primary method for students to meet the common core standard that calls “for students to exhibit a careful understanding and to have the ability to explain fine points of literacy texts” (p. 177). During close reading practice, students are encouraged to extract the meaning from the text, and note-taking is an excellent instrument that can help to achieve this goal (Snow & O’Connor, 2016).
The lesson plan adheres to the standards of the Virginia Department of Education (VDoE, 2010), which states that students in the fourth grade need to identify the main idea and summarize the contents of fictional texts. The lesson is appropriate for diverse learners as it includes differentiation, and the text analyzed during the class is free of racial or cultural prejudice or stereotyping. At the same time, according to Harmon (2012), the lesson adheres to the principles of culturally responsive teaching, as it empowers students and allows students with different cultural backgrounds to share their views about the story.
Novice teachers may experience problems with teaching reading comprehension as they do not know common issues that influence the success of students in close reading activities. The teachers need to realize that students in the fourth grade may experience difficulties with using background knowledge appropriately, word recognition, and vocabulary knowledge. Therefore, it is crucial that during the instruction, teachers demonstrate how they single out the main ideas of the text. The teachers should also be very attentive to students with diverse cultural backgrounds, as they may have different background knowledge and values. Teachers need to understand that all human beings are cultural creatures to use cultural diversity as an instrument to empower learners and enrich the classroom experience.